I'm not sure why the question is closed. It's no worse than many of the other "myth-id" questions. I personally think that many of these myth-id questions should be off-topic, for a variety of reasons. But I don't think it's fair to close one myth-id question and leave the rest open.
So, why is this question closed? And why hasn't it been reopened?
This question is currently at -2. But downvotes don't mean that a question should be closed; just that a question is poorly researched, unclear, etc.